INTERVIEW: “The weekend’s protests were the Russian peoples’, not the opposition’s” – Maxim Reznik
Western Balkans citizens legally resident in EU equal to 14% of region’s population
International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) has stripped Belarus of the right to hold the World Championship this year
Alexei Navalny arrested on arrival as he returns home
Russia's NorNickel adopts blockchain for supply chain management
Russia goes ahead with eSIM technology
Russia's retailer X5 Group posts 13% sales growth in 4Q20
National Bank of Ukraine retains a key policy rate at 6%, the outlook of the CPI deteriorates
Western Balkans and Ukraine urged to scrutinise coal subsidies
Oligarchs trying to derail Ukraine’s privatisation programme, warns the head of Ukraine’s State Property Fund
VISEGRAD BLOG: Central Europe's populists need a new strategy for Biden
LONG READ: The oligarch problem
OUTLOOK 2021 Lithuania
EBRD says loan to Estonia’s controversial Porto Franco project was never disbursed
Czech MPs pass protectionist food law in violation of EU rules
M&A in Central and Eastern Europe fell 16% in value in 2020, says CMS report
Hungarian vehicle makers hit by supply chain shortage
COVID-19 and Trump’s indifference helped human rights abusers in 2020
Polish industrial production continues boom in December
OUTLOOK 2021 Poland
OUTLOOK 2021 Slovakia
BRICKS & MORTAR: Rosier future beckons for CEE retailers after year of change and disruption
FDI inflows to CEE down 58% in 1H20 but rebound expected
Pandemic pushes public debt close to 80% of GDP in Albania and Montenegro
BALKAN BLOG: Superstition and resentment surround vaccination plans
Albania needs reforms for e-commerce to thrive, says World Bank
Bosnia's exports in 2020 amounted to BAM10.5bn, trade deficit to BAM6.3bn
Retailers and restaurant owners threaten protests in Bulgaria if reopening is delayed
Bulgaria's Biodit first company to IPO on new BEAM market
Bulgaria’s government considers gradual easing of COVID-related restrictions
Spring lockdown caused spike in online transactions in Croatia
ING: Growth in the Balkans: from zero to hero again?
Labour demand down 28% y/y in Croatia in 2020
Kosovo’s biggest opposition party risks being unable to run in general election
OUTLOOK 2021 Moldova
Storming parliaments: New Europe's greatest hits
World Bank revises projection for Moldova’s 2020 GDP decline to 7.2%
Montenegro’s special prosecution probes finance minister over €750mn Eurobond issue
North Macedonia plans to cut personal income tax in IT sector to zero in 2023
Romania government to pursue “ambitious” timetable for justice reforms
Private finance mobilised by development banks up 9% to $175bn in 2019
OUTLOOK 2021 Romania
BALKAN BLOG: US approach to switch from quick-fix dealmaking to experience and cooperation
Slovenia’s economic sentiment indicator up 2.2 pp m/m in January
Slovenia lost €10bn by neglecting wood industry for decades
OUTLOOK 2021 Slovenia
Slovenia’s opposition files no-confidence motion against Jansa cabinet
D’S Damat franchise deals ‘show Turkey’s hard-pressed mall operators becoming their own tenants’
Turkey’s benchmark rate held as concerns over faltering recovery come to fore
Turkish lira breaches HSBC’s stop-loss, Turkey ETF signalling outflows
CAUCASUS BLOG : What can Biden offer the Caucasus and Stans, all but forgotten about by Trump?
Armenia ‘to extend life of its 1970s Metsamor nuclear power plant after 2026’
OUTLOOK 2021 Armenia
OUTLOOK 2021 Azerbaijan
OUTLOOK 2021 Georgia
Iran’s President Khamenei menaces private citizen Trump
Iran’s technology minister indicted for failing to properly implement internet censorship
No US move to rejoin Iran nuclear deal imminent, say Biden national security nominees
TEHRAN BLOG: Will Biden bet on a quick return to the Iran nuclear deal?
Central Asia vaccination plans underwhelm, but governments look unruffled
Fears of authoritarianism as Kyrgyz populist wins landslide and backing for ‘Khanstitution’
OUTLOOK 2021 Mongolia
Mongolia's PM quits amid protests over treatment of mother with coronavirus and newborn baby
Mongolia's winter dzud set to be one of most extreme on record says Red Cross
Mongolian coal exports to China paralysed as Beijing demands virus testing of truck drivers
OUTLOOK 2021 Tajikistan
OUTLOOK 2021 Turkmenistan
Turkmenistan: How the Grinch stole New Year
COMMENT: Uzbekistan is being transformed, but where are the democratic reforms?
Download the pdf version
More...
Russia is now a mobilisation state, where everything from business to the arts can be dragooned to the Kremlin’s cause when it so wills. There is a particular connection between the world of business and the security agencies, with officers being seconded to companies, and corporations getting assistance from the spies. Rather than protecting national champions, though, this is actually encouraging inefficiency and stagnation.
A distinctively Russian phenomenon is the 'active reserve' system, whereby intelligence and security officers, especially from the Federal Security Service (FSB) are seconded permanently or temporarily to Russian companies and other institutions, from universities to media agencies, but are still technically working for their parent agency. They thus still have security clearance, still mingle with their old colleagues, and still get paid by the state, even while drawing a typically more generous outside salary.
The question becomes, who has their ultimate loyalty? The state clearly does this not out of the kindness of its own heart but because it wants to bind these institutions close. The active reserve officers are meant to be its eyes and ears, even while supporting national champion institutions. They also help facilitate activities that require more discretion and delicacy, whether arranging a suitable cover for a spy abroad or negotiating tribute for some public project dear to the Kremlin's heart.
Glory, honour and decorations may accrue from state service, as well as the profits of judicious corruption, but the private sector can typically pay much better. What was intended both as a lucrative perk to reward loyal and dedicated officers, as well as a way of embedding agents in the private sector, has become one more way the Russian state risks becoming privatised through the back door. These days, after all, anything from a parliamentary mandate to an arrest can be bought for the right price.
The case of General Oleg Feokostov illustrated this relationship perfectly. As deputy chief of the FSB's Internal Security Department, he apparently acquired the name of "General Fix" for his ability and willingness to sort out problems using the sweeping powers at his disposal. When Minister for Economic Development Alexey Ulyukaev took a stand in opposition to Rosneft's plans to buy a controlling stake in Bashneft, he became a problem for Rosneft's notoriously vengeful president, Igor Sechin. Feokistov reportedly initiated the investigation that led to Ulyukaev's midnight arrest on corruption charges in November of last year.
Feokistov then arranged an active reserve transfer, not so much a golden parachute, as a golden sidestep into, coincidentally enough, Rosneft, as a vice-president and the head of its security service. One FSB officer, whose career has been in the – incidentally much less lucrative – counter-terrorism sphere, bitterly described this as "a lot more than thirty pieces of silver".
He only had a little time to count them, though, as in March he was not only dismissed from Rosneft but also from the FSB. Setting up Ulyukaev alarmed too many within the elite. Besides, breathless – and inaccurate – accounts that Sechin essentially ran part of the FSB peeved and provoked its director, Alexander Bortnikov, enough that he needed to demonstrate his authority.
Carnivorous methods
As embedded officers come to identify with their new homes, whether for sentimental or pecuniary reasons, this even raises the spectacle of state security assets being deployed on both sides when companies clash. In one case in 2016, in which my source didn't want the names disclosed, his company's active reserve secondee used his contacts back in the FSB to collect kompromat – compromising material – on the CEO of a rival, which was contesting their award of a contract. It then emerged that their phones were meanwhile being tapped, courtesy of their rival's similar asset.
Of course it is not unusual for national champions to be supported by intelligence services and security agencies. Gazprom, Lukoil, and other major hydrocarbons companies, as well as any substantive player in the defence-industrial complex, has a FSB cell attached to it as a security asset and liaison unit.
Likewise, the Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR) routinely acts in support of major overseas bids. When Rosatom was contending for the Czech Temelin nuclear reactor contract, for example, the level of Russian espionage assets deployed to try and help them clinch the deal was infamous and helped contribute to Prague's decision to shelve the whole project in 2014.
Furthermore, having lost in the 2011-12 competition to land India's multi-role combat aircraft contract, now that it is being reopened, it is common knowledge in Moscow that the SVR is gearing up to do what it can to support the Russian bid. Of course, it is not as though their French, American and other rivals will not have their own government's assistance.
Overall, the impact of the close relationship between corporate and covert institutions in Russia matters much more at home than abroad. Internationally, they may be more commonly used in support of Russian companies, and perhaps more carnivorous in their methods, but the spooks fit into the same broad patterns as their foreign counterparts.
Domestically, though, the increasing ease with which corporate players can, in effect, rent the services of the FSB in particular cannot help but be a concern. It distorts the market, especially in the interests of the rich and the well connected. It also furthers the culture of corruption within the security agencies, something that will be hard to reverse. In good times, when the state is strong and the money plentiful, this may not mean much. However, when the state is weak or, as now, distracted and uncertain, and when the economy is not doing well, then it is another matter.
Russia's greatest economic challenges, after all, involve breaking out of inefficient and positively dysfunctional old patterns, of encouraging innovation and entrepreneurship. By allowing the old beasts to protect themselves from hungry young rivals with the shadow power of the state security agencies, the Kremlin is once again implicitly furthering stagnation.
Mark Galeotti is a senior researcher at the Institute of International Relations Prague, a visiting fellow with the European Council on Foreign Relations, and the director of Mayak Intelligence. He blogs at In Moscow’s Shadows and tweets as @MarkGaleotti.
Register here to continue reading this article and 5 more for free or purchase 12 months full website access including the bne Magazine for just $250/year.
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for free:
Already registered
Password could contain only a-z0-9\+*?[^]$(){}=!<>|:-_ characters and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your email address.
A confirmation email has been sent to the email address you provided.
Forgotten password?
Email field can't be empty.
No user with this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired. Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to with the subject line "Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have instructions on how to complete registration process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in case this communication was misdirected in your email system.
If you have any questions please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free subscription to bne's digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to the online package.
Click here for more subscription options, including to the print version of our flagship monthly magazine:
More subscription options
Take a trial to our premium daily news service aimed at professional investors that covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe:
Get IntelliNews PRO
For any other enquiries about our products or corporate discounts please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
If you no longer wish to receive our emails, unsubscribe here.
Magazine annual electronic subscription
Magazine annual print subscription
Website & Archive annual subscription
Combined package: web access & magazine print annual subscription