International Ice Hockey Federation (IIHF) has stripped Belarus of the right to hold the World Championship this year
Russian opposition activist Alexei Navalny arrested on arrival as he returns home
LONG READ: The oligarch problem
COVID-19 and Trump’s indifference helped human rights abusers in 2020
Russian opposition activist Navalny calls for supporters to take to the streets this weekend
One of Russia’s biggest wood product companies, Segezha could be Sistema’s next IPO
New Ukrainian VC firm QPDigital aims to invest up to $100 million in digital startups
EBRD investments reach record €11bn in pandemic-struck 2020
OUTLOOK 2021 Lithuania
EBRD says loan to Estonia’s controversial Porto Franco project was never disbursed
Estonian premier quits after Tallinn development scandal
Czech Pirates and Mayors approve final coalition agreement for 2021 elections
OUTLOOK 2021 Czechia
BRICKS & MORTAR: Rosier future beckons for CEE retailers after year of change and disruption
OUTLOOK 2021 Hungary
Hungarian government remains silent after Capitol riots
World Bank expects modest recovery for Europe and Central Asia in 2021
OUTLOOK 2021 Slovakia
FDI inflows to CEE down 58% in 1H20 but rebound expected
Slovakia to invest €1.2bn in digitisation
Corona-induced slump in global clothing sector dragged down Albania’s 2020 exports
BALKAN BLOG: The controversial recipe for building up Albania
Heavy flooding causes chaos in parts of Southeast Europe
Vodafone Albania plans €100mn infrastructure investments after AbCom merger
Turnover rose on Bosnia's two stock exchanges in 2020 while prices fell
Storming parliaments: New Europe's greatest hits
Kyiv accuses Bosnian President Dodik of lying about icon gifted to Russian foreign minister
Bulgaria’s government considers gradual easing of COVID-related restrictions
Sofia-based LAUNCHub Ventures holds first close of new fund on €44mn
ING THINK: Growth in the Balkans: from zero to hero again?
Labour demand down 28% y/y in Croatia in 2020
Zagreb Stock Exchange's Crobex10 index at highest level since March 5
OUTLOOK 2021 Kosovo
Arrera Automobili aims to launch Albania’s first supercar
World Bank revises projection for Moldova’s 2020 GDP decline to 7.2%
Moldova’s PM resigns to prepare the ground for early elections
Socialist lawmakers in Moldova scrap settlement on $1bn bank frauds
Montenegrins say state administration is most corrupt institution
75% of Montenegrins want EU membership
Montenegro’s new ruling coalition carves up top state jobs
North Macedonia's manufacturing confidence indicator down by 8.5 pp y/y in December
OUTLOOK 2021 North Macedonia
Transparency International warns of high corruption risk in CEE defence sectors
OUTLOOK 2021 Romania
Romania’s central bank cuts monetary policy rate by 25bp to 1.25%
Romanian construction companies' activity slows in November after intense 2020
OUTLOOK 2021 Serbia
Slovenia’s opposition files no-confidence motion against Jansa cabinet
Slovenia’s government to release funds to news agency STA after EU pressure
UK Moneyhub picks Slovenia for post-Brexit European base
Slovenia’s dire COVID-19 situation in 4Q20 caused second economic dip
Turkcell denies any affiliation with $1.6bn loan in default extended by Ziraat Bank to Virgin Islands company
BEYOND THE BOSPORUS: Let’s tentatively pencil in a date for Turkey’s hot money outflow
Armenia ‘to extend life of its 1970s Metsamor nuclear power plant after 2026’
OUTLOOK 2021 Armenia
COMMENT: Record high debt levels will slow post-coronavirus recovery, threaten some countries' financial stability, says IIF
Armenia’s PM cautions conflict with Azerbaijan “still not settled” after trilateral meeting with Putin
OUTLOOK 2021 Georgia
Georgia’s political kingpin Bidzina Ivanishvili quits politics
Modern-day “Robin Hood” inspires Georgians drowning in debt
Durov rejects Western funds’ offer to buy 5%-10% of Telegram with $30bn valuation
Iran’s navy conducts missile drill while analyst argues Trump even capable of nuclear strike in final days
TEHRAN BLOG: Who’s more credible? Johnson backing Trump’s Nobel chances or Iran applauding arrest warrant for US president?
Central Asia vaccination plans underwhelm, but governments look unruffled
Fears of authoritarianism as Kyrgyz populist wins landslide and backing for ‘Khanstitution’
OUTLOOK 2021 Kyrgyzstan
Mongolia's winter dzud set to be one of most extreme on record says Red Cross
Mongolian coal exports to China paralysed as Beijing demands virus testing of truck drivers
Mongolia fears economic damage as country faces up to its first local transmissions of coronavirus
Mongolia in lockdown after suffering first local coronavirus transmissions
OUTLOOK 2021 Tajikistan
China business briefing: Not happy with Kyrgyzstan
OUTLOOK 2021 Turkmenistan
Turkmenistan: How the Grinch stole New Year
Turkmenistan: The dammed united
COMMENT: Uzbekistan is being transformed, but where are the democratic reforms?
OUTLOOK 2021 Uzbekistan
Download the pdf version
More...
The dubious “Trump Dossier” has become a cypher that people invest with whatever meaning they most want to find, whether of the president-elect’s questionable character, or the determination of his enemies to undermine him. However, one key question in the endless back-and-forth interpretations is the sense that Russian policy is ruthlessly disciplined, long-sighted and coordinated. This is a dangerous misapprehension, as it blinds us to the realities of late Putinism. In particular, we need to be more aware that the relentless hollowing out of the institutions of the state have left Russia in the hands of what we could call ‘adhocrats’ – agents of the Kremlin who may come from the civil service or business, and operate fluidly across traditional roles as needs, orders and self-interest require.
Cultivating Trump
The essence of the “Trump Dossier” is, after all, the contention that for years, Moscow has actively been cultivating him, to the point that even before anyone else believed he had a chance in last year’s elections, cunning plans were being laid to win him the presidency, and a cast drawn from the top of the system was involved in negotiation, counselling and cheer-leading him.
Of course, any rich and powerful foreigner – especially an American – is of interest to the Russians. The Kremlin’s omnivorous intelligence services maintain files on everyone who comes to their attention, and whatever else one may say about Trump, he is hardly discreet or unnoticeable. This is what they do as a matter of routine, and it does not necessarily mean any particular interest in him.
As he became a political figure, then the Republican candidate, such interest sharpened. Despite Vladimir Putin’s public claims to the opposite, no one in Moscow seems to have believed he could prevail against Hillary Clinton, not least as, in a classic bit of mirror-imaging, it was assumed “the elites” would “manage” the election to make sure. They were clearly not above some mischief-making, leaking embarrassing emails in the hope of weakening and distracting Clinton, whom they feared would be a dangerous antagonist in the White House (and perhaps as payback for the Panama Papers leak, which was seen as a direct attack on Putin).
Putting aside the implausibility of so much in the “Trump Dossier” that reads like an anthology of the most outré water cooler and wine bar gossip one hears in Moscow, the irony is that it actually paints a picture not of coolly calculated conspiracy, but dysfunction and a kind of pluralism.
The rise of the ‘adhocracy’
It is hard to accept the claim that presidential spokesman Dmitri Peskov managed the whole “suborn/elect Trump” campaign, and also that such a broad cross-section of the upper elite would be involved (and be so universally loose-lipped about this above-top-secret programme). Nonetheless, one aspect of the dossier that does ring true is the degree to which this is an age in which the agents of the Kremlin, and the counsellors to the throne, can as easily be businesspeople or PR flacks as diplomats and scholars.
This, after all, is the essence of Putin’s ‘adhocracy’ – an elite defined by service to the needs of the Kremlin rather than institutional or social identity. The ministries are “below stairs”, essentially engines of the state, there to do whatever they are told. Even ministers are largely important insofar as they have a relationship to, and value for, the Kremlin, and that importance may well have little to do with their formal responsibilities. Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov has been largely kept out of major international decisions since Crimea in 2014, for example, (which may explain his rumoured departure from office this year). Conversely, when Moscow did decide to take Crimea, and realised it lacked the assets it needed on the ground, it turned to whoever was willing and able to raise the local muscle, in this case the financier Konstantin Malofeev.
What matters is not what your job title may be, or whether or not you are formally a state employee. After all, ever since the arrest of oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky and dispossession of his assets in 2003-5, it has been clear that even oligarchs are at best temporary stewards of assets at the Kremlin’s favour. Rather, the ‘adhocrats’ are defined by their loyalty, their capabilities, and what they can do today and tomorrow.
Vision, not plan
This is not just a reflection of an essentially personal model of rule. It is also a product of the largely incoherent and unplanned nature of late Putinism. It is not that Vladimir Putin has no sense of the Russia he wants to construct; quite the opposite, it is clear that he envisions his historical legacy as a Russia that is economically dynamic, stable and above all sovereign – which to him means not subject to the whims and influences of outsiders, including international laws and norms – and acknowledged as a great power.
Just as Marx and Engels could dream of a socialist state without bequeathing the Bolsheviks a blueprint which told them how public transport would be run and who would keep the sewers clean, so too Putin is much less clear on the detail as to how his vision is to be achieved. And while this can lead to policy incoherence, it is also a powerfully dynamic factor.
The ‘adhocrats’ become policy entrepreneurs, seeking and seizing opportunities to develop and even implement ideas they think will further the Kremlin’s goal, and hoping as a result to win its favour. Succeed, and you will be rewarded. Fail, and the Kremlin can disown you.
So in many ways, insofar as we can give it any credence, the “Trump Dossier” is being misread by those who want to find evidence of some long-term machinations. Rather, it is a tale of policy entrepreneurship at work. Spooks and other political operators monitoring and maybe even, on a passive and low-key way, cultivating a foreign magnate who might be of some use, some day. Other spooks – and two competing operations, at that – grazing through badly-secured internet traffic just in case it reveals something of interest. One agency (probably the Federal Security Service) pitching the idea of leaking some of that, to embarrass and undermine the presumptive next president and getting the green light from the Kremlin. And then, as much to its surprise as anyone else’s, Trump actually winning.
Russia is neither a chess grandmaster planning the next 20 moves ahead, nor a vodka-sodden drunk randomly weaving amidst the traffic. Rather, it can be considered a pluralistic authoritarianism, in which a variety of ‘adhocrats’ seek fame and fortune by finding their own ways of playing to Putin’s broad vision for the future. Sometimes that can lead to disaster, sometimes unexpected success. Indeed, Trump’s election may prove to be both at once. But either way, Western policy-makers need to understand this if they want to construct meaningful ways of engaging Russia in the future.
Mark Galeotti is a senior research fellow at the Institute of International Relations Prague, a visiting fellow with the European Council on Foreign Relations, and the director of Mayak Intelligence. He blogs at In Moscow’s Shadows and tweets as @MarkGaleotti.
Register here to continue reading this article and 5 more for free or purchase 12 months full website access including the bne Magazine for just $250/year.
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for free:
Already registered
Password could contain only a-z0-9\+*?[^]$(){}=!<>|:-_ characters and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your email address.
A confirmation email has been sent to the email address you provided.
Forgotten password?
Email field can't be empty.
No user with this email address.
Access recovery request has expired, or you are using the wrong recovery token. Please, try again.
Access recover request has expired. Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to with the subject line "Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have instructions on how to complete registration process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in case this communication was misdirected in your email system.
If you have any questions please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free subscription to bne's digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to the online package.
Click here for more subscription options, including to the print version of our flagship monthly magazine:
More subscription options
Take a trial to our premium daily news service aimed at professional investors that covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe:
Get IntelliNews PRO
For any other enquiries about our products or corporate discounts please contact us at sales@intellinews.com
If you no longer wish to receive our emails, unsubscribe here.
Magazine annual electronic subscription
Magazine annual print subscription
Website & Archive annual subscription
Combined package: web access & magazine print annual subscription