Turks spurning offer of cheap borrowing threaten Erdogan’s dream of big economic recovery says analysis

Turks spurning offer of cheap borrowing threaten Erdogan’s dream of big economic recovery says analysis
Erdogan, unhappy at high interest rates restraining lending, fired the central bank governor in July. Monetary easing has since hit a rapid pace, but lots of Turkish consumers seem resistant to taking on new debt
By bne IntelliNews November 7, 2019

Many Turks are spurning the offer of cheap borrowing brought about by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan forcing down interest rates, thus threatening plans for a big economic rebound pursued by the Turkish leader, according to a Bloomberg analysis released on November 6.

Erdogan wants Turkey’s economy, sent into recession earlier this year following the summer 2018 lira crisis, to recover with growth of 5% in 2020.

But many Turks, uncertain about the future, appear to be cutting back on investment and repaying debt instead of taking on loans made cheaper by monetary easing that has seen 1,000 bp wiped off their country’s benchmark interest rate since Erdogan, unhappy at a lack of rate-cutting, fired the central bank governor in July.

“Pessimism is at an all-time high,” Halit Direkci, who owns a $10mn poultry business in western Turkey, was quoted as saying. “I am investing less these days and rather focus on paying back all the loans I have withdrawn. I don’t want to make new investments through borrowing any more.”

Despite a raft of tax cuts and financial incentives, shoppers in Turkey are spending less than they were a year ago, meaning some local firms are struggling to sell their goods.

Turkey’s purchasing managers’ index, which measures manufacturing activity, fell back into negative territory in October as companies scaled back production due to a drop in demand at home and abroad.

“The main issue is the lack of confidence in the economy,” Zumrut Imamoglu, chief economist at TUSIAD, Turkey’s largest business group, was quoted as saying by the analysis.

Revenue at shopping centres in Turkey rose by 3.5% y/y in September, the Council of Shopping Centres – Turkey and Akademetre Research said in a report published on November 5, as cited by Ahval. Inflation was reported at an annual 9.3% during the month, meaning spending in real terms fell, just as it has for the past year.

Loans in Turkish lira, when adjusted for inflation, hardly grew in the three months to September compared with the previous quarter, when they contracted by 3.2%, Bloomberg noted. Fixed capital investment has contracted for four-straight quarters. At the same time, corporates are reducing their stock of foreign loans and expanding their holdings of foreign exchange.

The Turkish central bank rewards banks that grow their loan books by between 10% and 20% annually. It penalises those who do not.

“It will be challenging to kickstart growth through the credit channel,” European Bank for Reconstruction & Development (EBRD) President Suma Chakrabarti said in an interview with Bloomberg. “Corporates and banks are very heavily leveraged compared to 10 years ago. So it’s not going to be easy to stimulate the economy though this mechanism.”

Related Articles

Romania’s Banca Transilvania plans another takeover in Moldova

Banca Transilvania (BT), the biggest financial group in Romania, plans to take over Microinvest, the leader of the non-bank financial market in Moldova specialised in financing micro-enterprises, BT ... more

Further Turkey rate cut on Jan 16 expected by 13 of 21 surveyed economists

Thirteen of 21 economists surveyed by Reuters said they expected that the Turkish central bank would bring in another rate cut at its monetary policy committee (MPC) meeting on January 16. The ... more

Bulgaria's FIBank plans €103mn capital hike to meet ECB requirements

Bulgaria’s locally-owned First Investment Bank (FIBank) plans to raise BGN200mn (€103mn) in order to cover the capital shortfall found by the European Central Bank during an asset quality review ... more