Romania’s Jan-Apr budget deficit widens 49% y/y to 1.2% of GDP

By bne IntelliNews May 27, 2013

Romania’s budget deficit widened by 49.2% y/y to RON 7.5bn (EUR 1.7bn) in Jan-Apr, the finance ministry reported in a statement. The four-month deficit thus hit 1.2% of the full-year projected GDP, up from 0.85% calculated for Jan-Apr 2012. The wages paid in advance before Easter added a 0.2%-of-GDP contribution to the deficit, the ministry explained.

The annual rise is sharp but since it does not refer to full quarters, it is not entirely relevant and partly driven by in-advance public wage payments likely to reflect in lower May public payroll.* VAT collections shrank unexpectedly by 3.5% in April and the public payroll expanded by 52% y/y in the same month, based on our calculations. The two facts have contributed essentially to the doubling of the budget deficit to RON 3.3bn [0.5% of full-year GDP] in April alone – unless significant backward corrections were operated.

Even if not entirely relevant, the April budget execution adds some uncertainty to the government’s capacity to meet the fiscal consolidation target this year. The leftist cabinet has already expressed preference for looser fiscal policies. The ruling USL coalition has already announced it will enforce as of January 2014 either a 5pps VAT rate cut or a significant cut in the social security contributions. Both seem unrealistic steps at this moment.

Still, the 2.1% of GDP full-year deficit target remains feasible if the absorption of EU funds improves in line with expectations later this year. Romania wants to narrow the deficit to 2.1% of GDP this year from 2.5% in 2012. To achieve this, the government had to enforce new taxes that are expected to bring an additional 0.5%-of-GDP in revenue in 2013. Nonetheless the 0.5%-of-GDP rise in revenue to 31.6% of GDP is expected to be driven mostly by a 0.5%-of-GDP increase in EU funds absorption to 1.9% of GDP.

In Jan-Mar, the budget deficit was RON 4.2bn [0.67% of GDP] – in line with the quarterly targets set under the stand-by arrangement with the IMF. Nonetheless, the budget revenues fell short of the target in Q1 despite the stronger-than-expected GDP, budget minister Liviu Voinea admitted.

In April, budget revenue collections improved as the annual growth rate [of revenue] accelerated to 7.8% y/y from 3.0% y/y in Q1, based on our calculations. Delayed annual rise in excise taxes pushed the excise collections up 22% y/y explaining part of this. But the profit tax collection also improved to positive 7.8% y/y from negative 10.2% y/y in Q1. Notably, the VAT collection shrank 3.5% y/y in April after an encouraging 9.5% y/y rise in Q1.

On the expenditures side, public payroll surged 52% y/y in April, driven by Easter bonuses and in-advance payment of public wages in April -- also before Easter. Besides higher capital spending [possibly aimed at offsetting lower capital spending in Q1, when the budget planning was not endorsed yet], this largely explains the 16.2% y/y rise in total public expenditures.

* Companies/individuals can decide to make their quarterly payments in any month of the quarter.

General government budget                
(RON mn) 2012 y/y Q1 13 y/y 4M 13 y/y Apr-13 y/y
[1] Revenues 193,148 6.2% 47,038 3.0% 64,975 4.3% 17,937 7.8%
Profit tax 10,855 5.3% 2,917 -10.2% 5,009 -3.5% 2,092 7.8%
Income tax 20,957 9.9% 5,834 11.5% 7,617 11.0% 1,783 9.5%
VAT collections 50,516 5.4% 12,102 9.5% 15,986 6.0% 3,884 -3.5%
Excise taxes 20,260 6.0% 4,563 9.3% 6,674 13.0% 2,111 22.0%
Social sec. & Medicare contribution 51,658 2.0% 13,239 3.6% 17,994 5.9% 4,756 13.1%
Transfers from EU budget 7,979 30.6% 1,068 -33.8% 1,818 -10.6% 750 78.7%
[2] Expenditures 207,922 1.0% 51,226 4.4% 72,467 7.6% 21,241 16.2%
Payroll 40,799 6.2% 11,512 19.9% 16,604 28.2% 5,092 52.0%
Goods, services 34,444 8.4% 7,823 11.3% 10,880 8.1% 3,057 0.6%
Capital 19,305 -14.9% 3,595 -7.5% 5,357 7.6% 1,762 61.2%
Interest 10,711 20.6% 3,042 14.0% 4,386 9.9% 1,344 1.7%
Social security 67,049 -1.4% 16,961 1.0% 22,748 1.5% 5,787 3.3%
EU projects financing / transfers* 13,218 22.5% 1,897 -45.3% 3,326 -30.1% 1,429 10.7%
EU projects financing / other costs 1,614 n.a. 213 -38.3% 311 -36.7% 98 -32.8%
[3] Balance [1-2] -14,774 -38.2% -4,189 23.6% -7,492 49.2% -3,303 102.2%
Rev, % of GDP 32.9%   7.50%   10.4%   2.9%  
Exp, % of GDP 35.4%   8.20%   11.6%   3.4%  
Balance, % of GDP -2.52%   -0.67%   -1.20%   -0.53%  
Source: MoF, IntelliNews                
* include co-financing and funds disbursed from EU budget              
** includes principal loan repayments, bridge loans to EU-funded projects and similar          

Related Articles

Romanian media tycoon Voiculescu to be released on parole

A Romanian court ruled on July 18 that media tycoon and former politician Dan Voiculescu, who was sentenced to 10 years in prison in August 2014, should be released on parole after serving ... more

Evolution Equity Partners closes $125mn cybersecurity-focused fund

Evolution Equity Partners announced on 17 July the final closing of a new fund with total capital commitments of $125mn to make investments in cybersecurity and next generation enterprise software ... more

Romanian PM's adviser sacked after proposing tax on churches

Romanian prime ministerial adviser Eugen Teodorovici was reportedly dismissed from the post on July 14, the day after he spoke about the possibility of taxing the local Orthodox Church. Teodorovici ... more

Dismiss