Revised data reveals deeper losses for Romanian banks in 2012.

By bne IntelliNews May 30, 2013

Romania’s central bank revised the aggregated 2012 ROA for the banking system to minus 0.64% from previous 0.58%, data published by the monetary authority indicated. Based on this revision, we also adjusted the estimate for the 2012 net aggregated loss of the banking system to RON 2.35bn [EUR 530mn at eop exchange rate] from an earlier estimated RON 2.13bn [EUR 455mn].

The system’s loss in Q4 alone was RON 2.24bn [EUR 505mn]. The central bank does not disclose directly the aggregated profit/loss of the banking system, but leaked data confirmed our estimates* with a margin of a couple of percentage points.

ROA for the banking system, however, returned in the positive territory to plus 0.55% in Q1 – in annualised terms, the central bank also announced. Based on this, we have estimated an aggregated profit of RON 505mn [EUR 114mn] in the quarter. Earlier in May, leaked reports from the central bank indicated a RON 520mn [EUR 118mn] aggregated profit for Jan-Mar.

The capital adequacy of the banking system increased to 15% at the end of March this year from 14.6% at the end of 2012, the central bank said. The ratio stands well above the 10% level recommended by the central bank. Excessive solvency ratios tend to indicate inefficient use of resources and this is consistent with the local banks avoiding extending loans.

Largest lender BCR-Erste Group reported a 13% solvency ratio at the end of March 2013. The second largest bank, BRD-Societe Generale, reported a 14.6% ratio at end-Feb [as a proxy for end-Q1] and the ratio of the third largest lender - Banca Transilvania, was 12.2% at end-March.

* The main source of error in our estimates is the approximation of average assets with the average of assets at the beginning and at the end of the quarter.

Banking system ratios 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Q4 12 Q1 13
Assets (RON bn, eop,) 314.4 330.2 341.9 353.9 365.9 365.9 356.2
Capital adequacy 13.8% 14.7% 15.0% 14.9 14.6 14.6 15.0
ROA [1] 1.56% 0.25% -0.16% -0.23% -0.64% -0.64% 0.55%
ROE [2] 17.04% 2.89% -1.73% -2.56% -5.92% -5.92% 5.08%
Credit Risk Ratio [3] (%, eop) 6.5% 15.3% 20.8% 23.3% 29.9% 29.9% 30.0%
Non-performing Loans Ratio n.a. 7.9% 11.9% 14.1% 18.2% 18.2% 19.1
Loan to deposit ratio [4] 131% 119% 118% 119% 114% 114% 112%
RAS provisions (EUR mn) 1,904 3,540 5,498 7,117 8,848 8,848 9,281
IFRS provisions n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 6,644 6,644 7,055
RAS Provision cost (EUR mn) [5] 1,006 1,745 2,005 1,663 1,907 565 406
IFRS Provision cost (EUR mn) [5] n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 650 391
Aggr. Profit (EUR mn) [5] 1,107 193 -121 -181 -530 -505 114
Source: BNR

[1] (eop, annualised net profits per ytd/avg. assets) [2] (eop, annualised net profit per ytd/avg. equity) [3] Gross exposure of loans to non-bank clients and interest classified as doubtful and loss / Total classified loans to non-bank clients and related interest, excluding off-balance sheet items [4] loans/deposits to/of private sector alone [5] of period (year, quarter) converted at eop XR – also for the stock of provisions; for years may be different from the sum of quarterly values, which are converted at each quarter’s end-XR.

NOTE: We have simplified for better understanding the national accounting RAS and the international IFRS provisioning denominations. In fact, we are speaking about Prudential value adjustments under RAS [used until Jan 2012 for provisioning but still calculated afterwards] and Adjustments for impairment under IFRS [used after Jan 2012 for provisioning for fiscal purposes]. We recall that Romania's banking system shifted to IFRS since 2012 but is currently under a transition period when RAS reporting is still used for precautionary policies, while IFRS is used for taxation. Supplementary revenues resulting from the migration to IFRS have a special regime.

Related Articles

Romania’s Hidroconstructia starts overseas push with $115mn Jordan contract

Romanian civil engineering company Hidroconstructia has won a $115mn contract with Jordan’s Arab Potash Company, the world’s eighth largest potash producer. Hidroconstructia was founded in ... more

Romanian low cost carrier Blue Air reports 70% hike in passenger numbers

Passenger traffic of Romanian low-cost carrier Blue Air increased 70% y/y to 5mn last year, reported on January 21. The hike was supported by the increase in internal routes ... more

Romania’s Banca Transilvania becomes shareholder in Moldova’s Victoriabank

Romania’s Banca Transilvania (BT) has become a shareholder of Victoriabank, the third largest bank in the Republic of Moldova, with a total participation of over 66% alongside the European Bank for ... more